Yeah, weird. I made mine in the oven at around 400F also for about an hour and it came out just as white as it was when it went in. I don't recall what I heated it in because I made it a couple years ago and still have most of it left but most likely it was a corning glass casserole dish.
Either you're getting a weird reaction between the baking soda and the metal container or the metal container wasn't cleaned properly and its a reaction with something still on the inside thats stuck to the container or as kephra indicates, you may have tried to use baking POWDER and not baking SODA (a.k.a. sodium bicarbonate).
Baking powder is a concoction of a few different ingredients. Its absolutely not pure sodium bicarbonate.
Do let us know what the issue was once you figure it out. I, for one, am curious from an informational perspective.
Oh yeah, do not use what you've made already - there's obviously something wrong with it.